Butterscotch Pie- July Pie Pilgrimage

Is there a recipe in your family that has a history or maybe there's even a legend behind it?  Maybe there's a recipe that was once prepared by a beloved family member that is no longer with you and it was never written down and you have tried, in vain, to replicate it?

I've blogged about my maternal Grandmother many a time on here.  She was famous for entering recipe contests (and winning!), for pulling pranks (fake ice cube with fake fly, birthday cake candles that won't blow out, etc.) and for her butterscotch pie and homemade noodles.  Over the years, since her death, I have oftentimes regretted that I never took the time to spend an afternoon with her to learn how to make those noodles.  I craved them during the pregnancy of my firstborn.  Grandma was already gone by then and made me want them all that much more.

Her butterscotch pie recipe was published in a local cookbook many, many years ago and I have made this recipe many times over.  Each time trying to decide if I got it right, this time.  I swear, this was her final prank.  Publishing a favorite recipe and leaving out one of the key ingredients.  Maybe the key ingredient really was love, which means, the butterscotch pie simply never will be the same.

Grandma Blue's Butterscotch Pie

Here's What You Need:

2 cups whole milk or cream
2 cups dark brown sugar

4 heaping Tablespoons, flour
4 Tablespoons butter

2 egg yolks
1 deep dish baked pie shell

Here's What You Do:

This is one of those recipes that I never truly appreciated as a kid.  It's a rich dessert and one that my palate simply did not accept until, sadly, it was too late.  My brother called me earlier this summer asking me to walk him through the steps to make this pie.  He was making one to share with his son. 

Without further ado...the Legend of the Butterscotch Pie:

Go ahead and bake your pie shell and set it aside to cool.

Cream the brown sugar, flour, butter and egg yolks.  Heat the milk on medium and whisk in the sugar mixture before the milk gets too warm, otherwise, you'll end up with a scrambled egg mess and have to start all over again.  This has happened to me before and it's not fun!  Whisk constantly until the mixture comes to a boil.  Continue to whisk for one minute after it begins to boil.  Remove from heat and pour into the pie shell.  Let it cool a little and then chill in the fridge. 

Some recipes call for making a meringue but I prefer the way Grandma always served it and that was with a very healthy dollop of whipped cream! 

Warning:  So rich it makes your teeth itch!  No, really!